Back to top Back to top
  • close

Blog

Termination Clauses Are More Than Just a Collection of Words

Termination Clauses Are More Than Just a Collection of Words

For years, Ontario employers have watched courts strike down termination clauses because of a few problematic words, even where the employer arguably intended to comply with minimum employment standards. A few recent decisions suggest that courts may be shifting toward a more practical approach to interpreting these contracts.

In Henshell v. BFN of Ojibways, 2026 ONSC 5768, the Ontario Superior Court upheld a termination clause despite the employee’s argument that another part of the employment agreement could allow dismissal without the minimum payments required by law. The decision follows the Ontario Court of Appeal’s recent ruling in Baker v. Van Dolder’s Home Team Inc., 2026 ONCA 568, which aimed to clarify how courts should interpret contracts. Together, the decisions offer an indication of how courts may approach termination clauses going forward.

The Employment Relationship

Henshell was hired as the Chief Executive Officer of the Batchewana First Nation of Ojibways in May 2024, after practising law for approximately 20 years. Her employment ended less than three months later. She brought a wrongful dismissal lawsuit seeking pay in lieu of 24 months’ reasonable notice, along with additional compensation relating to her dismissal.

A wrongful dismissal lawsuit can be a dispute about how much notice or pay an employee should receive when their employment ends; it does not necessarily mean the employer wrongly accused them of misconduct or violated their human rights. Here, the central question was whether Henshell’s contract limited her to the minimum entitlements required by legislation, rather than a longer notice period under the common law (the rules developed by courts).

The employer argued that Henshell’s agreement limited her entitlements to those required by the Canada Labour Code (the Code) and asked the court to dismiss her lawsuit. The agreement expressly allowed the employer to end her employment for any lawful reason by providing those entitlements, without additional common law notice or pay in lieu of that notice.

However, Henshell pointed to another provision addressing workplace policies and confidentiality. It contemplated “termination for cause” for certain breaches. She argued that this wording could allow dismissal without the minimum entitlements required by the Code, making the termination provisions unenforceable. In practical terms, if her argument succeeded, the employer could not rely on the contractual limit to defeat her claim for a longer notice period.

Looking at the Contract as a Whole

The court rejected Henshell’s argument. Applying the approach recently confirmed by the Court of Appeal in Baker, it emphasized that each provision must be read in the context of the entire agreement. The question is what the contract, read objectively, shows the parties intended – not what either party privately meant.

It was not enough to identify a phrase that, viewed on its own, could theoretically allow a breach of employment standards legislation. The court instead considered whether the agreement, properly interpreted as a whole, demonstrated an intention to comply with the applicable legal minimums. Here, the termination provision expressly preserved Henshell’s entitlements under the Canada Labour Code, and the court concluded that the agreement did not allow the employer to avoid those obligations.

The practical result was that the contractual limit held and Henshell was not entitled to a longer common law notice period or pay in lieu of that notice.

Could Henshell Receive Additional Compensation for How She Was Dismissed?

Henshell also alleged that she had been dismissed in retaliation for raising concerns about legal expenses. In addition to notice pay, she sought moral and punitive damages.

The court drew an important distinction between why an employer decides to end employment and how it carries out the dismissal. An employee may have a claim for moral damages where an employer acts dishonestly, unfairly or in bad faith in the way it handles the dismissal as they are intended as compensation for harm arising from how the dismissal was handled. Punitive damages are intended to punish an employer rather than compensate the employee. A monetary award for these damages may be granted when the court determines that the employer’s behaviour was bad enough to justify such an award. However, simply alleging that the decision itself was unfair or retaliatory does not necessarily establish that claim.

Ultimately, the court dismissed Henshell’s lawsuit in its entirety.

What Does This Mean for Employers?

For employers, Henshell is another encouraging decision following Baker. The courts appear to be moving away from an approach that focuses excessively on individual words or hypothetical interpretations, and toward one that considers what the agreement actually means when read as a whole.

That does not mean employers can ignore problematic language. A clause that provides less than the minimum entitlements required by employment standards legislation will remain vulnerable to challenge. Nor does a general statement promising compliance with the law necessarily fix an otherwise unlawful provision.

There is also an important limit to the comparison with Ontario employers as Henshell involved a federally regulated employer governed by the Canada Labour Code, not Ontario’s Employment Standards Act, 2000 (ESA). Under the Ontario framework, having cause to dismiss an employee does not necessarily mean the employee loses their minimum statutory entitlements; the ESA’s “wilful misconduct” standard is distinct. The contract’s cause-related wording might therefore have produced a different result under the ESA. That remains a question for another court.

Nevertheless, the broader approach to reading contracts matters beyond federally regulated employment. For employers reviewing their agreements, the message is straightforward: draft termination provisions clearly and consistently and ensure they preserve the applicable legal minimums.

For employees and their counsel, Henshell serves as reminder that courts may be moving more toward assessing the contract as a whole rather than focusing on isolated words that could invalidate an otherwise lawful agreement.

Read the decision: Henshell v. BFN of Ojibways, 2026 ONSC 5768


AI Assisted Blog